16 matches (5W 5D 6L), goals: 18-22
| 05 DEC 1954 * | Italy - Argentina | 2:0 | Friendly |
| 24 JUN 1956 * | Argentina - Italy | 1:0 | Friendly |
| 15 JUN 1961 * | Italy - Argentina | 4:1 | Friendly |
| 22 JUN 1966 * | Italy - Argentina | 3:0 | Friendly |
| 19 JUN 1974 | Argentina - Italy | 1:1 | World Cup |
| 09 JUN 1978 | Italy - Argentina | 1:0 | World Cup |
| 26 MAY 1979 * | Italy - Argentina | 2:2 | Friendly |
| 29 JUN 1982 | Italy - Argentina | 2:1 | World Cup |
| 05 JUN 1986 | Italy - Argentina | 1:1 | World Cup |
| 10 JUN 1987 * | Italy - Argentina | 3:1 | Friendly |
| 21 DEC 1989 * | Italy - Argentina | 0:0 | Friendly |
| 03 JUL 1990 | Italy - Argentina | p.3:4 | World Cup |
| 28 FEB 2001 | Italy - Argentina | 1:2 | Friendly |
| 14 AUG 2013 | Italy - Argentina | 1:2 | Friendly |
| 23 MAR 2018 | Argentina - Italy | 2:0 | Friendly |
| 01 JUN 2022 | Italy - Argentina | 0:3 | Finalissima |
* Data might not be fully accurate. It needs to be verified with reliable sources. Want to help? Contact me at przemek@sobstel.org.